Get the app
CardSignals

American Express Green vs American Express SimplyCash: which earns more?

On typical spending, the American Express SimplyCash comes out about $13 a year ahead of the American Express Green, after fees and credits with no conditions.

Where each one wins

American Express Green: returns more on dining, travel, bills & subscriptions, transit, streaming, entertainment, drugstore and everything else.

American Express SimplyCash: returns more on groceries and gas.

American Express GreenAmerican Express · No annual fee · Membership Rewards points · 1.5¢ a point
American Express SimplyCashAmerican Express · No annual fee · Cash back

A typical year

Annual fee
NoneNone
Earns on typical spending
$425$438
Credits with no conditions
NoneNone
Net a year
$425$438Most value

What each earns, by category

Groceries
1x1.5% back2%2% back, bestUp to $15,000/yr (shared cap), then 1.25%
Dining
1x1.5% back, best1.25%1.3% back
Gas
1x1.5% back2%2% back, bestUp to $15,000/yr (shared cap), then 1.25%
Travel
1x1.5% back, best1.25%1.3% back
Bills & subscriptions
1x1.5% back, best1.25%1.3% back
Transit
1x1.5% back, best1.25%1.3% back
Streaming
1x1.5% back, best1.25%1.3% back
Entertainment
1x1.5% back, best1.25%1.3% back
Drugstore
1x1.5% back, best1.25%1.3% back
Everything else
1x1.5% back, best1.25%1.3% back

More on each card

Add a third card, or try others, in the comparison tool.

How this is worked out

Both cards are checked on the Canadian household average spending by category (Statistics Canada, Survey of Household Spending 2023), on their own, at the CardSignals conservative point value, with caps included. The net counts the annual fee and the statement credits that renew with no condition. Welcome bonuses are left out: they pay once.

The CardSignals app makes the same comparison against the cards you already hold, on your own spending. Card details checked on September 29, 2026. Rates and fees change; check with the bank before you apply.

Compare against the cards you hold

These pages compare cards on their own. CardSignals ranks the cards you already hold for each purchase, on your own spending. Free for 2 open cards.

Get Signal Check

Card news, standout deals, and new tools, straight to your inbox once a month. Plus one note the day Android is on Google Play.

By signing up you agree to get Signal Check, the monthly CardSignals email, and app news from CardSignals, Toronto, Canada, M5V 0N1, support@cardsignals.ca. Unsubscribe anytime from any email.