Get the app
CardSignals
GuidesFee payback

Has your card paid for itself this year?

A card with an annual fee pays for itself when what you got from it is more than what it cost you. The honest count uses what you actually used and paid, not the totals on the card's page.

The count

Rewards you earned + credits you actually used − the fee you actually paid

Above zero, the card paid for itself this year. Below zero, it cost you money, and it is worth a look before the next fee posts.

1. The fee you actually paid

Start from your statements, not the card's advertised fee.

  • A first-year fee waiver means you paid $0 this year.
  • A monthly fee adds up over the year. For example, the American Express Cobalt Card in Canada is $15.99 a month, equal to $191.88 a year, outside Quebec. (source 1)
  • Add any fees for extra cardholders on the account.
  • Take off any fee refund or retention credit the bank gave you.

2. The credits you actually used

  • Count only credits that posted to your statement. A credit you didn't use is worth $0 to you, however large it is.
  • A credit spent on something you wouldn't have bought otherwise is worth less than its face value. Count what it was worth to you.
  • Match each credit to its period. Some run by calendar year, like the $200 Annual Dining Credit on the American Express Platinum Card in Canada (source 2). Others run by card year: Chase Sapphire Reserve's $300 travel credit counts from your account open date (source 3). Compare a card year's credits with that card year's fee.

3. The rewards you earned

Multiply the points the card earned by a conservative value per point, the value you can count on getting, not the best possible redemption. The points value calculator shows the conservative values CardSignals uses. Cash back counts at face value.

If you hold other cards, the fairest figure is what this card earned beyond what your next best card would have earned on the same purchases. The one card calculator shows how much the right card for each purchase is worth.

An example with round numbers

Not a real card, just the count:

  • Fee paid this year: $150.
  • Credits: $200 available, $100 used. Count $100.
  • Rewards: 20,000 points at a conservative 1 cent each. Count $200.
  • $200 + $100 − $150 = $150. This card paid for itself, with $150 to spare.

Had none of the credits been used, the count would be $200 − $150 = $50: still ahead, but by much less than the card's page suggests.

Sources

Each page was read on November 16, 2026. Terms change: the bank's page and your cardholder agreement have the final word.

  1. 1. American Express Canada, American Express Cobalt Cardhttps://www.americanexpress.com/ca/en/credit-cards/cobalt-card/The fee is $15.99 a month (equal to $191.88 a year) outside Quebec, and $191.88 a year in Quebec.
  2. 2. American Express Canada, The Platinum Card: Dining and Eventshttps://www.americanexpress.com/en-ca/benefits/dining-and-events/the-platinum-card/The $200 CAD Annual Dining Credit: each calendar year is a separate redemption period, it resets on January 1, the Card must be charged before the end of each period (December 31), and credit not redeemed does not roll over.
  3. 3. Chase (US), Chase Sapphire Reservehttps://creditcards.chase.com/rewards-credit-cards/sapphire/reserve$795 annual fee. The $300 travel credit is annual from your account open date (the card year, not the calendar year). The dining credit is up to $150 from January 1 to June 30 and up to $150 from July 1 to December 31. Points don't expire as long as the account stays open.

Track your points and cards in CardSignals

CardSignals tracks the cards you hold, with no bank login: your credits, fees and what each card earns you. Free for 2 open cards.

Get Signal Check

Card news, standout deals, and new tools, straight to your inbox once a month. Plus one note the day Android is on Google Play.

By signing up you agree to get Signal Check, the monthly CardSignals email, and app news from CardSignals, Toronto, Canada, M5V 0N1, support@cardsignals.ca. Unsubscribe anytime from any email.